Novels like "The Secret History" by Donna Tartt

  1. 1
    If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio

    Set at a prestigious conservatory dedicated to Shakespearean acting, this novel closely mirrors the atmosphere of Tartt's classic. A tight-knit group of friends passionately devoted to Shakespeare become drawn into complicated relationships.

    As emotions intensify, tragedy inevitably strikes. The novel dives into guilt, morality, and obsession, echoing the same dark tone and suspenseful narrative that made "The Secret History" unforgettable.

    With richly layered characters and dramatic tension, "If We Were Villains" explores the dangerous edges of friendship and the darker consequences lurking beneath intellectual obsession.

  2. 2
    Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir

    Although set in a sci-fi world, "Gideon the Ninth" captures that isolated, intellectually tense atmosphere that made "The Secret History" so striking. A group of young necromancers in training gather in a hauntingly secluded mansion to compete and unlock secret knowledge.

    Tensions, rivalries, and hidden agendas quickly surface, driving the story towards suspenseful conclusions.

    Even amidst fantasy elements, its darkly academic vibe—featuring eccentric, ambitious characters and lethal contests—calls vividly back to the exclusive, morally ambiguous friend groups that fans of Tartt found irresistible.

  3. 3
    Bunny by Mona Awad

    "Bunny" presents a twisted, surreal version of the dark academia trope. Set among pretentious writers in an exclusive MFA program, the story follows Samantha, pulled reluctantly into a clique of girls calling each other "Bunny."

    What begins as satire soon spirals into genuinely unsettling territory filled with dark humor, mystery, and strange transformations. Awad captures academia’s elitist pretensions brilliantly, simultaneously mocking and exploring tight-knit friend groups’ obsessions and rituals.

    If you appreciated Tartt's subtle critiques of academic insularity, Awad's grotesque yet compelling "Bunny" provides an intriguing next read.

  4. 4
    Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo

    Set at Yale, Bardugo plunges readers into a world of secret societies whose privileged members dabble not just in wealth and power, but dangerous occult magic.

    The atmosphere, with its dark history and elements of mystery and ghosts, closely calls to mind the chilling, secretive mood Tartt established. Protagonist Alex Stern, troubled yet determined, maneuvers through tangled webs of tradition and corruption to expose sinister secrets.

    Engaging with privilege, moral ambiguity, and supernatural suspense, “Ninth House” captures Tartt's hallmark themes in a fresh, compelling light.

  5. 5
    The Likeness by Tana French

    Tana French's uniquely suspenseful novel revolves around Cassie Maddox, a detective who assumes the identity of a murdered graduate student.

    She infiltrates the student's insular friend group, living in their shared home and piecing together the truth behind the girl's mysterious death. Employing psychological depth, French examines intricate relationships tied together by secrets, ambition, and hidden jealousies.

    Readers familiar with the tense, cloistered friendships depicted in "The Secret History" will immediately recognize the similar careful dance between loyalty, guilt, and deception here.

  6. 6
    Brideshead Revisited by Evelyn Waugh

    Waugh's classic novel explores class, religion, and complicated relationships at Oxford University in pre-war Britain. The story revolves around the bond between Charles Ryder and Sebastian Flyte, whose friendship transforms them both profoundly.

    With exquisite prose, Waugh effectively portrays privilege, nostalgia, and the weight of moral and spiritual conflict. Like Tartt’s characters, Waugh’s protagonists struggle with identity and loss, shaped profoundly by their experiences at an elite institution.

    The complex portrayal of intense friendships and morality resonates clearly with the compelling character dynamics of "The Secret History."

  7. 7
    Special Topics in Calamity Physics by Marisha Pessl

    Following highly intelligent student Blue van Meer, this novel shares a central premise similar to Tartt's: a precocious protagonist joins a charismatic teacher and a select student group, leading inevitably toward mystery and tragedy.

    Both narrators adopt dramatized unreliability, peppering their profound insights with literary references and sharp observations.

    The intellectual cultural overtones, dramatic relationships, and slow-building tension make this gripping novel distinctly reminiscent of Tartt's uniquely academic, psychologically suspenseful storytelling.

  8. 8
    Gentlemen & Players by Joanne Harris

    Set within the cloistered halls of St. Oswald's, an elite British boys' school, Harris unravels a tale steeped in rivalry, buried pasts, and psychological suspense. Told through dual narrations, readers uncover deceptions and ambitions festering within the academy.

    Secrets and revenge fuse perfectly with explorations of class privilege. Fans of Tartt’s attention to hidden motives and murky morality in elite educational settings will appreciate the intricate plotting and slow-burning revelation of dark truths in "Gentlemen & Players."

  9. 9
    Plain Bad Heroines by Emily M. Danforth

    This lush Gothic story chronicles two timelines at a cursed girls' boarding school renowned for strange, tragic events.

    Featuring a metafictional twist and compellingly queer themes, Danforth delves into female friendships, secret bonds, and dark academia threaded through suspense and horror.

    The vivid portrayal of institutional secrecy, romantic intrigue, and complicated interpersonal dynamics resonates strongly with the moody, introspective narrative that Tartt mastered.

    The richly atmospheric prose and intricate dual-layered mystery make this novel an engrossing companion to "The Secret History."

  10. 10
    A Separate Peace by John Knowles

    At a sheltered boys' boarding school in wartime New England, Gene and Finny form an intense friendship overshadowed by envy and misunderstanding. A tragic event reshapes their relationship, impelling Gene to confront morality, friendship, and guilt.

    Knowles carefully crafts his story, depicting friendships darkened by rivalry and insecurity against a backdrop of youthful innocence corrupted irreversibly.

    The stark portrayal of psychological tension and moral consequence aligns "A Separate Peace" powerfully with the themes woven into Tartt's novel.

  11. 11
    The Rules of Attraction by Bret Easton Ellis

    Set at affluent liberal arts institution Camden College, Ellis unapologetically portrays a generation consumed by nihilism and amorality. The affluent students wastefully pursue excess, drugs, and fragmented relationships without purpose or sentimentality.

    While tonally sharper and marked by Ellis’s distinct cynicism, the novel captures similar themes of campus alienation, corrosive privilege, and moral decay.

    Readers intrigued by Tartt’s exploration of darker collegiate realities and morally ambiguous students will find a compelling echo here, albeit through a different narrative lens.

  12. 12
    Catherine House by Elisabeth Thomas

    Set in an exclusive, experimental university where isolation and secrecy reign, "Catherine House" presents an eerie, atmospheric interpretation of academic darkness.

    Students sacrifice outside contact during their three-year stay, immersing themselves entirely within this strange institution’s rituals. Mysteries unfold slowly, revealing deeply disturbing truths beneath the polished façade.

    Thomas employs psychological suspense brilliantly to create a chilling ambiance and closely guarded secrets reminiscent of Tartt’s own sinister campus setting, equally devoted to secrecy and intensive intellectual pursuit.

  13. 13
    Vita Nostra by Marina and Sergey Dyachenko

    In this surreal fantasy, Sasha enrolls in a mysterious university where education causes terrifying transformations both physically and psychologically. The line between learning and transformation blurs dangerously, drawing from philosophy and psychological intrigue.

    Themes of intellectual struggle and isolation recall Tartt’s insular academic setting and relentless pursuit of hidden knowledge.

    Complex, imaginative, and strikingly original, this novel offers a distinctly unique entry point to the dark academia genre, replete with the moral ambiguity and intense atmospherics readers admired in Tartt's work.

  14. 14
    The Truants by Kate Weinberg

    Weinberg's campus thriller follows Jess Walker as she attends university specifically because of her admiration for charismatic professor Lorna Clay.

    Becoming deeply absorbed into Lorna's privileged circle of students, Jess navigates shifting loyalties, complicated relationships, and hidden desires that escalate into tangled secrets and betrayal.

    Psychological complexity and close-knit, elitist groups tie this novel distinctly to the themes pioneered by Tartt, exploring obsession, idealism, and human fallibility within dark, intellectually charged settings.

  15. 15
    Black Chalk by Christopher J. Yates

    Six Oxford University students begin playing a sinister and manipulative game that spirals dangerously, leaving psychological scars long afterwards.

    Featuring dual timelines and unreliable narrators, this psychological thriller keeps the tension high, relentlessly peeling back layers of memory and deceit. Yates explores unresolved guilt, spiritual emptiness, and the devastating consequences of youthful missteps.

    The tightly wrought, distracting camaraderie and dramatic fallout in "Black Chalk" echoes powerfully with Tartt’s emphasis on friendship, intellectual competitiveness, and lurking moral disaster.